UNION DUES / LABOR LAW REFORM / AFL-CIO
Michigan Union Dues Law Upheld
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit May 23 affirmed a district
court decision upholding a Mich. law that requires labor unions to obtain
permission from members at least once a year before using their dues for
political contributions. This paycheck protection law, which also
applies to employers, requires the annual written consent of any person
who has an automatic paycheck deduction that is used for political purposes.
The Mich. AFL-CIO challenged this law in 1998, arguing that the burden placed on the unions' political speech was excessive and unconstitutional. The Mich. AFL-CIO lost. The court dismissed the Mich. AFL-CIO's argument that the law burdens freedom of speech more than is necessary by forcing the unions to resort to a face-to-face method of solicitation in order to obtain member permission for political donations.
"The governmental interest in this case is the right of the individuals not to contribute to unfavored political causes," Judge Alan E. Norris wrote in the decision. Norris also cited the court's 1997 ruling that "even if contributors were to decline, ... the cause would be the exercise of informed choice by individuals, not the government suppression of political advocacy."
Judge Harry Wellford filed a concurring opinion on the case, stressing that the law furthers a governmental interest without burdening free speech. "There is no constitutional right to have union dues deducted from payroll or for a check-off in the first instance," Wellford wrote.
This was the second time the case had come before the Sixth Circuit. In 1997, the appeals court had reversed a district court decision to grant a preliminary injunction to enjoin enforcement of the law. The Sixth Circuit disagreed with the lower court's use of the First Amendment strict scrutiny test, and instead decided the case based on an intermediate scrutiny test. [BNA 6/8/00]
Union Corruption Update is made possible by the generous contributions from readers like you. NLPC, P.O. Box 6273, McLean, VA 22106-6273. Thank you.
In addition to the unions and organizations covered in this Union Corruption Update, readers can look forward to news and information on other corrupt and abusive unions in future editions.
All back issues of the Union Corruption Update can be viewed at NLPC's website (www.nlpc.org). Also available is a union-by-union and state-by-state index of all Union Corruption Update articles.
If you have story ideas or suggestions for future editions of Union Corruption Update, please email NLPC at nlpc@nlpc.org. Thank you.
Union Corruption Update is part of NLPC's Organized Labor Accountability Project which is investigating and exposing corruption and extremism in the Teamsters, LIUNA, AFL-CIO and many other union organizations. NLPC is a nonpartisan, nonprofit foundation promoting ethics and accountability in government through research, education and legal action.
Union Corruption Update Article Index (by Union)
Union Corruption Update Article Index (by State)
Organized Labor Accountability Project